Up to four vehicles, side by side

Compare

Pick two, three or four vehicles from our full index of cars and vans. We'll show you which wins on each measure that matters to a used buyer.

MG HS

SUV

Kia Sportage

SUV

Nissan Qashqai

SUV

Hyundai Tucson

SUV

Maximum 4 vehicles — remove one to swap another in.

4 of 22 categories

MG HS

MG HS

SUV

3 of 22 categories

Kia Sportage

Kia Sportage

SUV

7 of 22 categories

Nissan Qashqai

Nissan Qashqai

SUV

2 of 22 categories

Hyundai Tucson

Hyundai Tucson

SUV

What they’re worth

Estimated private-sale value, valued at the same mileage on the same model as each car’s own profile page.

MG HS

2021 reg · 1.5 T-GDI 162 Excite

£12,600

Kia Sportage

2022 reg · 1.6 T-GDi HEV

£18,050

Nissan Qashqai

2022 reg · 1.3 DIG-T 158 mHEV N-Connecta

£12,550

Hyundai Tucson

2022 reg · 1.6 T-GDi Hybrid

£16,600

Round by round

MG

HS

Kia

Sportage

Nissan

Qashqai

Hyundai

Tucson

Headline
Price when new
£31,500
£31,400
£29,170best
£33,150
Average MPG
43 mpg
44 mpgbest
44 mpgbest
44 mpgbest
Reliability score
76/100
72/100
82/100best
75/100
High-severity issues
0 knownbest
1 known
2 known
1 known
Signals
Cam drive type
—
Chain
Chain
Chain
MOT outlook
Above avg (75th)best
Average (43rd)
Below avg (37th)
Above avg (60th)
ULEZ / CAZ
Compliant
Compliant
Compliant
Compliant
On-road trend
+36.9% ↑best
+10.7% ↑
+3.0% ↑
+11.1% ↑
Longevity
Value loss · 0–5 yrs
53.2%
51.6%best
54.1%
53.2%
Value loss · 5–10 yrs
21%
21.8%
20.7%best
21%
Value loss · 10–15 yrs
9%
9.3%
8.8%best
9%
Running costs
Annual servicing
£185best
£230
£220
£235
Insurance group
Group 16
Group 15
Group 12best
Group 18
Road tax
£200
£200
£200
£200
EV reality check
Winter range
—
—
—
—
DC charge 10–80%
—
—
—
—
Heat pump
—
—
—
—
Battery chemistry
—
—
—
—
Size & weight
Boot space
1,600 L
—
—
—
Length
4,600 mm
—
—
—
Kerb weight
1,750 kg
—
—
—
History
First year sold
2019–2026
2017–2025best
2017–2025best
2017–2025best

"Best" marks the strongest vehicle on a single measure for a used buyer — lower cost, lower depreciation, more space, better reliability. Ties and unavailable data are left unmarked. Categorical fields (heat pump, battery chemistry) aren't scored. It doesn't tell you which car is better overall.

What goes wrong

MG HS

Reliability 76/100

  • medium

    Tyres & wheels · 60k-100k miles · £80-£500

  • medium

    Brakes · 60k-100k miles · £150-£500

  • low

    Driver's view · 60k-100k miles · £60-£300

  • low

    Lighting & signalling · over 100k miles · £15-£120

  • low

    Identification & other · over 100k miles · £20-£150

Kia Sportage

Reliability 72/100

  • high

    Theta II engine (pre-2020) · 60k+ · £0 (recall) – £4,000

  • medium

    DCT (7-speed) · 50k+ · £250 (oil) – £2,500 (clutch pack)

  • medium

    DPF (diesel) · 80k+ · £700–£1,500

  • low

    Battery (12V auxiliary on hybrids) · 50k+ · £120–£200

  • low

    Rear tailgate strut · 70k+ · £60–£120

Nissan Qashqai

Reliability 82/100

  • high

    DPF (diesel) · 70k+ · £800–£1,800

  • high

    Xtronic CVT (pre-2021) · 60k–100k · £2,000–£3,500

  • medium

    Drive belt / alternator · 80k+ · £300–£600

  • low

    Rear suspension links · 70k+ · £200–£350

  • low

    Touchscreen infotainment (Mk3) · Any · £200–£400

Hyundai Tucson

Reliability 75/100

  • high

    Theta II 2.0/2.4 engine (pre-2020) · 60k+ · £0 (recall) – £4,000

  • medium

    DCT (7-speed) · 50k+ · £250–£2,500

  • low

    Touchscreen / nav freezing · Any · £0 (software) – £500

  • low

    PHEV charging port · 30k+ · £200–£400

  • low

    Rear wiper motor · 60k+ · £150–£250

SearchCompare with