Up to four vehicles, side by side
Compare
Pick two, three or four vehicles from our full index of cars and vans. We'll show you which wins on each measure that matters to a used buyer.
MG HS
SUV
Kia Sportage
SUV
Nissan Qashqai
SUV
Hyundai Tucson
SUV
Maximum 4 vehicles — remove one to swap another in.
4 of 22 categories
MG HS
SUV
3 of 22 categories
Kia Sportage
SUV
7 of 22 categories
Nissan Qashqai
SUV
2 of 22 categories

Hyundai Tucson
SUV
What they’re worth
Estimated private-sale value, valued at the same mileage on the same model as each car’s own profile page.
MG HS
2021 reg · 1.5 T-GDI 162 Excite
£12,600
Kia Sportage
2022 reg · 1.6 T-GDi HEV
£18,050
Nissan Qashqai
2022 reg · 1.3 DIG-T 158 mHEV N-Connecta
£12,550
Hyundai Tucson
2022 reg · 1.6 T-GDi Hybrid
£16,600
Round by round
MG
HS
Kia
Sportage
Nissan
Qashqai
Hyundai
Tucson
"Best" marks the strongest vehicle on a single measure for a used buyer — lower cost, lower depreciation, more space, better reliability. Ties and unavailable data are left unmarked. Categorical fields (heat pump, battery chemistry) aren't scored. It doesn't tell you which car is better overall.
What goes wrong
MG HS
Reliability 76/100
- medium
Tyres & wheels · 60k-100k miles · £80-£500
- medium
Brakes · 60k-100k miles · £150-£500
- low
Driver's view · 60k-100k miles · £60-£300
- low
Lighting & signalling · over 100k miles · £15-£120
- low
Identification & other · over 100k miles · £20-£150
Kia Sportage
Reliability 72/100
- high
Theta II engine (pre-2020) · 60k+ · £0 (recall) – £4,000
- medium
DCT (7-speed) · 50k+ · £250 (oil) – £2,500 (clutch pack)
- medium
DPF (diesel) · 80k+ · £700–£1,500
- low
Battery (12V auxiliary on hybrids) · 50k+ · £120–£200
- low
Rear tailgate strut · 70k+ · £60–£120
Nissan Qashqai
Reliability 82/100
- high
DPF (diesel) · 70k+ · £800–£1,800
- high
Xtronic CVT (pre-2021) · 60k–100k · £2,000–£3,500
- medium
Drive belt / alternator · 80k+ · £300–£600
- low
Rear suspension links · 70k+ · £200–£350
- low
Touchscreen infotainment (Mk3) · Any · £200–£400
Hyundai Tucson
Reliability 75/100
- high
Theta II 2.0/2.4 engine (pre-2020) · 60k+ · £0 (recall) – £4,000
- medium
DCT (7-speed) · 50k+ · £250–£2,500
- low
Touchscreen / nav freezing · Any · £0 (software) – £500
- low
PHEV charging port · 30k+ · £200–£400
- low
Rear wiper motor · 60k+ · £150–£250