Head to head · City car
Fiat 500 vs Toyota Aygo X
On the measures that matter most to a used buyer — value retention, reliability, fuel economy and insurance — the Toyota Aygo X comes out ahead of the Fiat 500, winning 3 of the 4 categories where the two differ.
| Measure | Fiat 500 | Toyota Aygo X |
|---|---|---|
| Est. value, ~3 years old | £9,550 (2023, 18,500 mi) | £11,050 (2023, 18,500 mi) |
| Value kept after 3 years | 68% · wins | 63% |
| Reliability (MOT-derived, /100) | 81 | 87 · wins |
| Average mpg | 55 | 62 · wins |
| Insurance group | 8 | 7 · wins |
| Road tax / year | £200 | £200 |
| Typical annual service | £185 | £185 |
Valuations are each model's ~3-year-old example at typical mileage, through the same model behind the profiles. Adjust mileage, trim and condition in the interactive comparison →
500 vs Aygo X — quick answers
Which is more reliable, the 500 or the Aygo X?
The Toyota Aygo X scores higher on Forecourt's MOT-derived reliability measure — 87 against the Fiat 500's 81 out of 100.
Which holds its value better, the 500 or the Aygo X?
The Fiat 500 — it keeps about 68% of its original price after three years, against 63% for the Toyota Aygo X.
How much does a used 500 cost compared with a Aygo X?
A roughly three-year-old Fiat 500 is worth about £9,550 at typical mileage, against about £11,050 for the equivalent Toyota Aygo X.